• Welcome to CivicXI.com everyone!

    If you're joining us from CivicX.com, then you may already have an account here!

    As long as you were registered on CivicX.com as of May 24, 2020 or earlier, then you can simply login here with the same username and password!

mbaapk

Senior Member
First Name
Mike
Joined
Mar 30, 2022
Threads
24
Messages
2,139
Reaction score
2,207
Location
Twin Cities
Vehicle(s)
Pacifica
So basically we like/dislike these cars for very different reasons. Sounds like I love everything you hate about the R.

I love the fact that the CTR makes me work harder. Its limits are reached quickly, which is part of the appeal. I donā€™t even have to drive fast or wind it out in order to feel like Iā€™m sprinting. In the M2C, I have to be doing triple digits, and looking at serious jail time to have fun. Thatā€™s exactly what I miss about cars: the feeling of driving slower cars fast.

The thing I canā€™t stand about M2ā€™s is the power surge at low revs. There is this sudden ā€œspikeā€ in the powerband, which is when you hit that long, wide torque ā€œplateauā€ (around 3000RPM). Itā€™s like a ā€œflat zoneā€ range where power is constant as revs rise due to falling torque. Thatā€™s what I generally experience going to redline with the S55. In this ā€œflat zoneā€, thereā€™s a sensation that thereā€™s little reward for continually revving out and you almost feel like short-shifting. Then again, the OG M2 experience is slightly different.

I canā€™t enjoy an M2 unless I drive it fast, very fast. Driving it slow just sucks. To me, itā€™s uneventful and far less engaging at lower speeds than the R. And letā€™s face it, 90% of all driving is done at lower speeds, but I suppose it depends where you live.

As for the sound, the OG M2 does sound good to me. Definitely better than the Type R and M2C, which both sound muted. Too much fake noise being pumped into the cabin anyway, but thatā€™s the case with every performance car nowadays.
Good post. Id only add that if sound is an issue to buy an aftermarket exhausT. Although im thinking 11gen will solve for this shortcoming.
Sponsored

 

avalanche011

Member
First Name
Eric
Joined
Oct 28, 2019
Threads
0
Messages
20
Reaction score
10
Location
California
Vehicle(s)
Tesla Model Y, Porsche GT3 and C5 Z06
More electronics = more things to go wrong.

I had a sunroof on prior cars and never again. Long term, things always break. If the seals donā€™t give out and it doesnā€™t develop a leak, then the motor and other moveable parts start to break down.

I personally donā€™t think any of these parts have a place on a performance focused car.

Once you start adding heated seats, heads up display, heated steering wheel, sunroof, power seats, leather trim/upholstery, high end sound systems with subs and extra speakers, cameras, safety systems, and other fancy-shmancy crap, you slowly turn into a BMW. And thatā€™s not a complement because theyā€™ve all gotten heavy af over the years for exactly this reason. New M3 starts a tad under 3,900 lbs and approaches 4,000 lbs loaded. That is insane.

CTR already removed the mechanical e-brake. Iā€™m not fond of this, but Iā€™ll give it a pass.
That is why slick top BMWs are most sought after due to reduce complexity and head room, lower CG and weight reduction. Its a shame they are so hard to come by because the average buyer wants all these unnecessary features in their performance cars.
 
Last edited:

Boostlag

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2017
Threads
2
Messages
1,948
Reaction score
1,058
Location
Arlington, VA
Vehicle(s)
MK7.5 GTI
I dont care for sunroofs but damn I'll never buy a car that doesn't have heated seats. I've been spoiled. I also love parking sensors front, sides and back on my GTI but I guess I could live with out those.
 

Rhorn

Senior Member
First Name
Robert
Joined
Mar 24, 2022
Threads
1
Messages
627
Reaction score
567
Location
Florida
Vehicle(s)
GT350 , Civic Type R
I went from my 2018 FK8 to a 2020 BMW M340i with the new gen B58 engine. I absolutely loved my Type R but just as IQBad stated the FWD in the FK8 was useless in the first half of the gears(I was tuned as well). My M340 is a totally different beast in terms of power delivery but i must admit a Type-R is fun as hell. Personally one of the reasons i got away from the type r was i missed the luxury's of a sunroof, heated seats and a decent sound system. If the new Type-R would have a version with these features i would be much more interested. Currently waiting delivery of my 2022 Si (canadian version) which has a ton of features. Due to the inflation of everything i have decided to get back into Honda reliability and low maintenance cost compared to BMW and i am really looking forward to my new Si but will for sure keep tabs of the Type-R Features.
Yeah I honestly did a lot of thinking and the no sunroof and heated seats are definitely 2 pretty big cons for me. I know that its a sports car and some guys will argue but I do like the creature comforts as I have Raynauds Disease and need the warmth. I ensured that my GT350 had heated seats, I liked the recaro race seats but you couldn't get any heating/cooling unless you got the standard leather seats. I am new to Florida and I can overlook the heated seats because of the heat, but I will miss having a sunroof not going to lie about that.

Later down the line I can see myself trading in the CTR for the Integra Type S or a Type R for the performance in addition to the nice extra luxuries if I ever want something a bit more subtle. The other hatchbacks/liftbacks on the market I am not a fan of. Would be nice if Honda at least offered heated seats as an option but I understand their reasoning
 

mbaapk

Senior Member
First Name
Mike
Joined
Mar 30, 2022
Threads
24
Messages
2,139
Reaction score
2,207
Location
Twin Cities
Vehicle(s)
Pacifica
Well the Civic is really for commuting and daily driving. I understand sunroof will decrease performance so I agree with that. But how much performance would heated seats really decrease? It probably adds no more than 5lbs to the overall weight!
Thats about added cost and not performance. The new one will probably be 1-2k more as it is. With tax, markup and full body ppf id be looking at $54k. If no heated seats means keeping the starting price lower - im all for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 007


davemarco

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2017
Threads
21
Messages
1,888
Reaction score
82
Location
California
Vehicle(s)
2019 Civic Type R (CBP), 2013 Audi TTRS
I used to have a FK8,but I switched to an M2 (normal, not a comp) and I have to say that overall the M2 is a better car. The FK8 has some serious flaws that makes it really annoying:

1. FWD just limits acceleration grip in all everyday situations. The car never felt fast to me because in normal speeds (up to like 4:th gear) it just spins up it wheels! (Mine was tuned) The M2 with is RWD just hooks up and you can make quick accelerations from dead stops or to pass cars without loosing grip.

2. The engine is very laggy, if you are in 2:nd gear at like 3000rpm and floor the pedal, you donā€™t even get max boost until you run out of revs and have to shift, and then it starts all over again. This engine needs a DSG toget rid of all the lag.

3. The sound the engine makes is just bad, there is no joy in listening to it. On the m2 just hearing the engine rev match as you shift down is amazing!

Now the new CTR looks much better than the FK8 that is positive, and it comes with very wide tires stock, good for track! I am just hoping that they fixed at least the engine sound, this would make the car appeal more to me, but I donā€™t see myself swapping out an m2 for this right now at least.
Based on the Suzuka video, I don't think that they've improved the sound at all. What I heard sounded very similar to the fake engine noise on the 2020+ FK8.

I really don't understand it - every other manufacturer seems capable of making a good sounding engine/exhaust but Honda. Even with my REMUS exhaust, my Type R is decidedly meh on sound.
 

007

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2022
Threads
1
Messages
357
Reaction score
600
Location
USA
Vehicle(s)
2023 GR Yaris - Circuit Pack
I really don't understand it - every other manufacturer seems capable of making a good sounding engine/exhaust but Honda. Even with my REMUS exhaust, my Type R is decidedly meh on sound.
Well, almost every car nowadays has a turbocharger and sounds like crap as a result. Some just sound less terrible than others IMO.

New BMWā€™s all sound like crap, unless they got a V8. And even those sound terrible for a V8.

Mercedes with their 4-bangers now is criminal with sound. Same goes for Toyota, Mazda, Nissan, etc.. Muffled af due to turbos and regulations.

The days of good sounding exhausts are long gone. Thatā€™s not to say that some cars donā€™t sound decent. Fiat Abarth sounds good, for example. So does the A45 AMG.

To me, most aftermarket exhausts just amplify what is already a terrible note. But I admit the way we view exhaust noise is very subjective, sort of like looks.
 

mbaapk

Senior Member
First Name
Mike
Joined
Mar 30, 2022
Threads
24
Messages
2,139
Reaction score
2,207
Location
Twin Cities
Vehicle(s)
Pacifica
Well, almost every car nowadays has a turbocharger and sounds like crap as a result. Some just sound less terrible than others IMO.

New BMWā€™s all sound like crap, unless they got a V8. And even those sound terrible for a V8.

Mercedes with their 4-bangers now is criminal with sound. Same goes for Toyota, Mazda, Nissan, etc.. Muffled af due to turbos and regulations.

The days of good sounding exhausts are long gone. Thatā€™s not to say that some cars donā€™t sound decent. Fiat Abarth sounds good, for example. So does the A45 AMG.

To me, most aftermarket exhausts just amplify what is already a terrible note. But I admit the way we view exhaust noise is very subjective, sort of like looks.
Just need burbling like the N.
 
Last edited:

davemarco

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 3, 2017
Threads
21
Messages
1,888
Reaction score
82
Location
California
Vehicle(s)
2019 Civic Type R (CBP), 2013 Audi TTRS
Well, almost every car nowadays has a turbocharger and sounds like crap as a result. Some just sound less terrible than others IMO.

New BMWā€™s all sound like crap, unless they got a V8. And even those sound terrible for a V8.

Mercedes with their 4-bangers now is criminal with sound. Same goes for Toyota, Mazda, Nissan, etc.. Muffled af due to turbos and regulations.

The days of good sounding exhausts are long gone. Thatā€™s not to say that some cars donā€™t sound decent. Fiat Abarth sounds good, for example. So does the A45 AMG.

To me, most aftermarket exhausts just amplify what is already a terrible note. But I admit the way we view exhaust noise is very subjective, sort of like looks.
I agree, though on the spectrum of decent sounding 4cyl turbos, I feel like the R is one of the worst. Of course it's particularly tough when the other car in the stable plays sweet 5cyl turbo music. Every time I go back to the Type R from the RS, I have to shut the valve on my REMUS. It's no bueno.
 


ASIMO Assassin

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2021
Threads
0
Messages
72
Reaction score
74
Location
Canada
Vehicle(s)
Nothing interesting right now
More electronics = more things to go wrong.

I had a sunroof on prior cars and never again. Long term, things always break. If the seals donā€™t give out and it doesnā€™t develop a leak, then the motor and other moveable parts start to break down.
This

When I originally ordered my Audi DD, I was able to delete the panorama sunroof (and TMPS). I've never to this day come across another one that doesn't have one.

The glass and mechanism weigh 104 kg (~230lbs), all well above the centre of gravity. It has noticeable improvements in handling and acceleration compared to versions with the sunroof I've driven. Plus I never have to worry about leaking or the dreaded sunroof explosions. Another nice thing about it that I couldn't predict was that my hair would start to fall out.... so bonus, so no bald spot sunburns!

Less electronics and moving parts translates to longevity. My DD is now just over 9 years old, not a single issue yet... fingers crossed, haha.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 007

ApexEight

Senior Member
First Name
Anthony
Joined
Jul 13, 2018
Threads
0
Messages
388
Reaction score
35
Location
Atlanta, GA, USA
Vehicle(s)
2008 Honda Civic Si sedan
Sunroof is a big no for me. Helmet room is underrated. Heated seats I can understand, especially for those in colder climates. Lol @ the guy saying FWD sports car with turbo 4s are a mistake.
 

fredzy

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2021
Threads
2
Messages
173
Reaction score
186
Location
PA
Vehicle(s)
Sienna, GR86, FL5
So about this Suzuka lap.. I notice the car bouncing a lot through corners at grip threshold. Nobody commented on that, and Honda clearly seems OK with it so Iā€™m guessing thatā€™s considered a normal-ish behavior in FWD world? Can anyone weigh in on why thatā€™s happening? I think they need to soften some dampers.

This behavior is lethal (though very rare) on RWD cars.. I was waiting for him to bounce into the gravel on the T11 hairpin. With the front wheels dragging the car along I see that the risk is much lower, but it definitely exacts a cost. I would be desperate to tune that out of the car. Clearly the speed trade off of keeping the thing so stiff was worth it because their fast lap exhibited it.

Ultimately doesnā€™t matter too much since I wouldnā€™t take this to the track, but Iā€™d definitely experience it from time to time in how Iā€™d drive the car. Iā€™m considering upgrading my DD in the next year, CTR has been sort of top of my list. The biggest problem I see is obtaining one. Iā€™m second in line at a no-markup dealer for a GR Corolla (thatā€™s one silver lining that came out of my awful struggle to obtain a GR86 this year!) but Iā€™m having trouble seeing myself spend $40k on that car, as fun as it will be. It will be very special but I donā€™t think I would necessarily enjoy it more than the CTR.
 

mbaapk

Senior Member
First Name
Mike
Joined
Mar 30, 2022
Threads
24
Messages
2,139
Reaction score
2,207
Location
Twin Cities
Vehicle(s)
Pacifica
So about this Suzuka lap.. I notice the car bouncing a lot through corners at grip threshold. Nobody commented on that, and Honda clearly seems OK with it so Iā€™m guessing thatā€™s considered a normal-ish behavior in FWD world? Can anyone weigh in on why thatā€™s happening? I think they need to soften some dampers.

This behavior is lethal (though very rare) on RWD cars.. I was waiting for him to bounce into the gravel on the T11 hairpin. With the front wheels dragging the car along I see that the risk is much lower, but it definitely exacts a cost. I would be desperate to tune that out of the car. Clearly the speed trade off of keeping the thing so stiff was worth it because their fast lap exhibited it.

Ultimately doesnā€™t matter too much since I wouldnā€™t take this to the track, but Iā€™d definitely experience it from time to time in how Iā€™d drive the car. Iā€™m considering upgrading my DD in the next year, CTR has been sort of top of my list. The biggest problem I see is obtaining one. Iā€™m second in line at a no-markup dealer for a GR Corolla (thatā€™s one silver lining that came out of my awful struggle to obtain a GR86 this year!) but Iā€™m having trouble seeing myself spend $40k on that car, as fun as it will be. It will be very special but I donā€™t think I would necessarily enjoy it more than the CTR.
You should watch the LE do the ring if you have not already. That was bouncing, skipping on roids.
Sponsored

 
 




Top