zumbooruk
Senior Member
- Joined
- Oct 19, 2024
- Threads
- 12
- Messages
- 708
- Reaction score
- 674
- Location
- Ventura CA
- Vehicle(s)
- 2025 FL5, 2014 Chevy Suburban (wife), previous 2007 FA5
No.Curious, did you try the Mobil 1 Extended Performance M1-110A Oil Filter, since you use the Mobil ESP oil? I'm thinking of trying one of these or just stick to the PurolatorONE?
Mobil 1 used to be made by First Brands, parent company of Fram, before they went belly up. Mobil 1 oil filters are now made under contract by Highline Warren LLC. Cons are the coarser published micron rating and an unproven maker change. Do not treat today’s M1-110A as the same filter that was tested five years ago.
Note that further research indicates that PGI made filters might be better than Purolator ONE (see below)
Mobil 1 have shifted their contracts elsewhere. Highline Warren LLC has been the exclusive U.S. and Canada supplier of Mobil 1 since February 2025. Highline Warren is the contracted brand supplier and warranty party but the physical cans are contract-built. Recent stock and shipping records often point to Korea or Vietnam. Construction often looks like the Premium Guard private-label filters, though Highline Warren has said it is not connected to Premium Guard, yet the appearance still overlaps...
AI summary of the current best oil filters. excluding the original Fram/Amsoil/Royal Purple.
note that the top three are current PGI made filters. which is encouraging if Fram/Amsoil/Royal Purple will be relabeled PGI. though best would be if they would make them identical to the First Brands Champion Lab construction.
Disclaimer, below was generated by AI. "Don't Trust, AND Verify"
For the common Honda M20 × 1.5 spin-on used on the K20C1 (15400-PLM-A02 size), the filters that currently best match high 15–20 µm efficiency, high flow, a tight bypass that cracks toward the upper end of the usual 8–17 psi band, a working anti-drainback valve, and a reliable gasket are PGI’s extended-life group first, then MANN+HUMMEL’s PurolatorONE and Wix lines, then the Japan Mahle Honda can. Independent ISO 4548-12 data at 15–20 µm is sparse and often contradicts box claims. Rankings below use published ISO figures when they exist and conservative estimates when they do not. Fram Ultra Synthetic, Amsoil, and Champion Labs Royal Purple are omitted as requested.
How the ranking was applied
Efficiency at 15–20 µm is first. Clean flow and pressure drop are second. Bypass leakage and a higher crack pressure are third. Dirt capacity and burst strength are ignored. Construction of the anti-drainback valve and gasket is noted when it is a known strength or weakness.
Ranked filters
Carquest Premium (PGI / VAFI, Honda-size 84356 or current 57356-class Premium SKU). This is the strongest current match to the stated criteria among filters that still have a published ISO 4548-12 number near 20 µm. Advance Auto and Carquest list 99.5 percent efficiency at 20 µm on synthetic-blend media. Cut-opens and owner reports consistently show a silicone anti-drainback valve and a silicone or high-grade gasket that stays soft. Flow is in the normal PGI range, not the lowest restriction in the class, but it is adequate on a short 5,000 mile interval. Bypass is a conventional spring design in the common 8–11 psi band, which is the main con. That set point is lower than ideal if the goal is to stay on the filtered path during cold, thick oil. QC from PGI’s Vietnam lines has been more consistent than the disrupted First Brands plants. https://bobistheoilguy.com/forums/threads/all-about-carquest-oil-filters.390750/
Premium Guard Extended Life / Ultimate (PGI house brand, Honda-size PG equivalent of 57356). Same factory family as Carquest Premium. Published figures are 99 percent multi-pass at 20–25 µm depending on the exact SKU sheet. Silicone anti-drainback and a heat-stable gasket are standard on the extended-life cans. Pros are the same media and valve package as Carquest Premium, often at a lower street price, plus PGI’s own QC rather than a newly acquired Fram line. Cons are inconsistent micron wording across PGI brand sheets (20 µm on one page, 25 µm on another) and a bypass that is not documented as a high-crack, low-leak design. Treat it as equal to Carquest Premium when the can is the extended-life version with pink or red silicone rubber. https://bobistheoilguy.com/forums/t...rquest-premium-microgard-select-specs.391952/
Microgard Select (O’Reilly, PGI). Same PGI extended-life construction as Carquest Premium. O’Reilly publishes 99 percent at 25 µm. That is a slightly coarser advertised point, so estimated 15–20 µm efficiency is a little below Carquest Premium even if the media looks identical in cut-opens. Silicone anti-drainback and gasket are the usual PGI parts. Flow is comparable. Bypass is again the ordinary 8–11 psi class. The con is the more conservative published micron number and the fact that O’Reilly also sells a cheaper Microgard that is not the Select. Buy only the Select can. https://www.oreillyauto.com/detail/c/select/microgard-select-oil-filter/
PurolatorONE PL14610 (MANN+HUMMEL). Historically this was one of the few filters marketed at 99.9 percent at 20 µm with a silicone anti-drainback valve and a PTFE-treated gasket that resists leaks and eases removal. Flow is generally good and restriction is moderate. Pros are the parent company’s real filtration engineering, a gasket design that has a long clean record, and wide availability. Cons are that current packaging often says only “over 99 percent dirt removal” without a 15–20 µm ISO figure, and independent multi-pass results on related Purolator SKUs have not always matched the old PureONE claim. Bypass is typically mid-band, not the high end. Still a first-line choice if PGI stock is unavailable. https://www.amazon.com/Purolator-PL14610-PurolatorONE-Oil-Filter/dp/B000E8V9RG
Wix 57356 (MANN+HUMMEL). Wix currently lists about 99 percent at 23 µm, 9–11 gpm flow, and an 8–11 psi bypass on this Honda-size can. Independent flow benches usually put standard Wix among the lowest-restriction filters in the group, which is a real plus for turbo oil pressure after a cold start. Silicone anti-drainback and a quality gasket are standard. Cons are the 8–11 psi bypass (opens earlier than you asked for) and the fact that Wix’s 23 µm claim is not a 15–20 µm ISO result. Older Wix data sat near 50 percent at about 20 µm. Use it when flow matters more than the last few points of 20 µm capture. https://www.go-parts.com/ps-product-new.php?sku=4DAFDE9
Wix XP 57356XP (MANN+HUMMEL). Same can family with synthetic-blend media aimed at longer intervals. Flow is the best measured result in the Ascent 30 L/min bench among the filters still in this list (about 5 psi differential on that rig). Construction, anti-drainback, and gasket follow the regular Wix pattern. Cons are more serious on your first criterion. An independent ISO 4548-12 run on the XP line returned only about 62 percent at 20 µm against a 95 percent at 35 µm advertisement. Bypass remains 8–11 psi. XP is the flow leader, not the 15–20 µm leader. https://www.speed-talk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=63818
Honda 15400-RTA-003 (Mahle Tennex, Japan). This is the better genuine Honda can. Cut-opens show metal structure, a silicone anti-drainback valve that stays pliable, a Honda-profile gasket that seals on the factory base, and a bypass Honda calibrated for this engine family. Flow is OEM-matched to the K20C1 pump curve. Efficiency at 15–20 µm is not published as a high Beta figure. Estimate is typical OEM, roughly 50–80 percent at 20 µm, well below PGI’s 99.5 percent claim. Pros are fit, gasket, anti-drainback, and a bypass that is meant for Honda oil pressure (idle minimum about 13 psi hot). Cons are ordinary, not class-leading, fine-particle capture. Prefer this over the US 15400-PLM-A02 if you want OEM. https://www.hybrid-racing.com/products/oem-k-series-oilfilter
Mobil 1 Extended Performance M1-110 / M1-110A (Highline Warren since February 2025). Older Mann-built Mobil 1 filters were among the lowest-restriction cans and used a 12–16 psi bypass, which is closer to the high end you want. Current boxes still advertise about 99 percent at 30 µm, not 15–20 µm, so estimated 20 µm efficiency is mid-pack. Highline Warren is now the exclusive supplier. Recent cans are reported from Korea or Vietnam, sometimes with plastic end caps. Anti-drainback and gasket quality on the new production is not independently mapped the way the old Mann cans were. Pros are historically excellent flow and a higher bypass band. Cons are the coarser published micron rating and an unproven maker change. Do not treat today’s M1-110A as the same filter that was tested five years ago. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-rel...c-relationship-with-exxonmobil-302443331.html
Purolator BOSS PBL14610 (MANN+HUMMEL). This filter scores well on your second and third criteria and poorly on the first. Bypass is listed around 14–18 psi, the highest common figure in this size. Flow is good (about 6.8 psi drop at 30 L/min in the Ascent bench). Silicone anti-drainback and a PTFE gasket are in the Purolator premium kit. The problem is efficiency. The same independent ISO 4548-12 test that confirmed Fram Ultra at 99.96 percent at 20 µm measured BOSS at 61.8 percent at 20 µm. It is a high-flow, high-bypass filter that lets through too many 15–20 µm particles for a tight turbo journal. https://www.speed-talk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=63818
Honda 15400-PLM-A02 (current US dealer can, Honeywell / Fram-type construction). Fit and gasket profile are correct. Bypass is often quoted in the 11–17 psi window. Anti-drainback is present. Efficiency is the weak point. This can has long been treated as a basic cellulose or light-blend filter, with forum estimates near 50–70 percent at 20 µm and fiber end caps on many lots. It meets Honda’s minimum, not the 15–20 µm target. Use it only when a better can is not on the shelf. https://bobistheoilguy.com/forums/threads/the-honda-oil-filter-thread.394222/
NAPA Gold in the current PGI era (Honda-size 1356 / 57356 equivalent). When the can is PGI-built rather than old Wix-built, it belongs with Microgard Select. Some sheets say 99 percent at 23 µm. Silicone anti-drainback is common on recent pink-gasket lots. Confirm the can is the current PGI construction, not leftover Wix Gold, because the two are not the same product anymore. Bypass remains the 8–11 psi class. https://bobistheoilguy.com/forums/threads/here-are-premium-guards-main-oil-filter-suppliers.387629/
Sponsored